Emac's Stock Watch | Fox Business
  • December 12, 2008 12:45 PM EST by Elizabeth MacDonald

    Blame the Bailouts on Mister Rogers?

    Blame the record bailouts on Mister Rogers.

    Mister Fred Rogers, the children's TV star, who, beginning in 1968, started every show telling us that we were "special" just the way we were.

    When we weren't.  

    Blame all of those preening child-rearing experts who encouraged an excruciatingly costly culture of entitlement, a culture of narcissism, of excessive self-righteous self-indulgence, where generations grew up believing they were entitled to follow their own codes of conduct, a chronic "me first, I get what's mine first" attitude--to the point where one survey shows one in three teenagers expect to be famous.

    Better yet, blame the bailouts on everyone who forgot the most important part of the Mister Rogers' Neighborhood show, a willful ignorance that has led to a mass dereliction of civic duty, of civic vision--Rogers' emphasis on "neighborhood."

    Blame it on a post World War II culture of "me-ism," of individuality over community, of "I'm special, you owe me," a culture of anything goes in this Age of Aquarius.

    A mindset which has resulted in more than half of the country's annual $14 tn in GDP, $7.8 tn, a quantum leap in fiscal debt, now being committed to bail out the economy.

    Concrete proof that equal opportunity means everyone will have a fair chance at being incompetent, to quote Laurence J. Peter, author of the "Peter Principle."

    A staggering bailout sum that has any semi-conscious, prudent taxpayer who pays their bills on time lying in a stark awake coma at three in the morning, taxpayers who grew up with their personal motto: "I think, therefore I am debt-free."

    A crisis fueled by a housing finance system, distorted for seven decades by the government, which has now gone begging for a government bailout.  

    Congressmen practically herniated themselves before the crisis blew up to defend the mismanaged, near insolvent mortgage finance giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, their political cash machines, with chest-beating, stiff-necked fulminations, proving when it comes to your tax dollars, they have Van Gogh's ear for fiscal probity (to paraphrase the filmmaker Billy Wilder).

    In one year, households have lost in net worth the equivalent of about half of the country's annual output, $7.1 tn, from $63.6 tn in the third quarter of 2007 to $56.5 tn in the third quarter of 2008, Federal Reserve data show. 

    Has Your Head Exploded Yet?

    US taxpayers now own investments in 174 banks, without knowing the guidelines that were used to waste their money, says bank analyst Richard Suttmeier.

    Fannie and Freddie have been allowed to expand their mismanaged multi-trillion dollar portfolios, along with $200 bn in taxpayer money to cover their losses.

    And despite the open fire hydrant of liquidity the US government has pointed at the financials, a new wave of writedowns could cut deeply into these funds, as securities built on risky loans are still priced for the Ice Age.

    Meanwhile, in the runup of the credit bubble from 2002 to 2007, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan Chase, Merrill Lynch, Lehman Bros. and Bear Stearns had paid an estimated total of $312 bn in compensation and benefits to its employees, compensation largely based on false profits.

    And what have taxpayers witnessed in this fiasco? An orgy of juvenilia. Which even Romper Room's Miss Louise has had to deal with.

    Romper Room's Miss Louise Mugged

    "Former Romper Room hostess Mary Ann King (in Los Angeles from 1966-76) was mugged in the parking lot of a Hometown Buffet in Los Angeles on December 17, 2003. The encounter gave King, 70, a broken arm, rib and punctured lung."

    "Besides her injuries, the thieves stole a black taffeta bag that contained the original Magic Mirror (white plastic mirror frame) used on the Romper Room program so many years."

    At the end of every show, Miss Louise would delight children across the country, singing Happy Birthday through her Magic Mirror to children on camera, naming their names.

    However, in an act of generosity and kindness, "King began carrying the magic mirror around with her to satisfy the wishes of people who confronted her with the allegations ‘you never said my name.'"

    Nice to put your neuroses on a sweet senior citizen who made you happy. The Fellowship of Juvenilia grows (although Miss Louise's Magic Mirror does suspiciously look like a destrung badminton racket).

    The Orgy of Juvenilia

    *Ten million borrowers, many of whom should never have borrowed what they did to begin with, could go bellyup on their mortgages when all is said and done. Monthly foreclosure filings, most of which are in suburban middle class neighborhoods, could grow to 303,000 monthly from 259,085, says RealtyTrac.

    *In Bakersfield, California, a Mexican strawberry picker with an income of $14,000 and no English was lent every penny he needed to buy a house for $720,000. A nanny for a mortgage-bond trader at Deutsche Bank bought, along with her sister, five townhouses in Queens, New York after lenders got them to refinance to keep buying.--Michael Lewis, "The End of Wall Street's Boom."

    Proving that when people are free to do as they please, they usually imitate each other. Here's more:

    *Less than a week after the government rescued AIG with an $85 bn loan, AIG executives spent $440,000 of company money on a week-long executive getaway at a beach resort in California, including $23,000 on spa charges. This, after the insurer also promised $20 mn in compensation to AIG's former chief executive Martin Sullivan. AIG's bailout cost to date: $150 bn.

    *AIG ostensibly told market watchdogs it was freezing its bonus pool for executives, but then disclosed "retention" payments for 168 employees, including 13 executives, up to $4 mn for certain managers. The insurer said it disclosed its initial list of 130 managers in a September filing without saying how much each of the recipients would receive, but then added another 38 employees.  

    *Citigroup's $306 bn bailout, a massive government backstop of bad assets, carries no demand from the government that any executives who mismanaged Citi resign. Included in this sum, the government also bought $27 bn in preferred shares in Citi which carry an 8% dividend, lower than the 11% dividend Citi owes the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority, which invested $7.5 bn in Citigroup's preferred shares in November 2007. The deal "was not about punitive, it was about financial stability," said Citi's chief financial officer Gary Crittenden.

    *Citigroup's top executives, including Robert Rubin, have yet to announce they actually have given up their bonuses this year. Rubin denies responsibility for the bank's massive losses stemming from its incompetent bets, despite the fact he encouraged more risk-taking at the bank in 2004 and 2005.

    *Wall Street institutions "are now gone or re-organized and our financial system is in crisis," says Sen. Chuck Grassley. "As [SEC] Chairman Christopher Cox said himself [in testimony]," the SEC's Wall Street oversight "'program was an utter failure.'"  

    *SEC Chairman Christopher Cox blames the current crisis on "real estate boom-and-bust cycles" of markets in an editorial for the Wall Street Journal and in testimony. Cox confesses that regulators failed to take into account that "secured funding..could become completely unavailable," and that regulators and Wall Street firms firms never used "risk scenarios based on a total meltdown of the US mortgage market," the most serious and realizable risk of all. 

    *However, nowhere does Cox admit that the SEC "utterly failed" in its oversight of the credit rating agencies, who rubberstamped triple-A ratings on mortgage-backed paper at the root of the crisis, notes Barry Ritholz of the Big Picture Typepad, or the ramifications regarding how the SEC relaxed its Wall Street capital oversight rules in 2004, and how that subsequently resulted in firms levering up 40-to-1, debt versus assets, starting in 2004.

    *While touting their Bear Stearns hedge funds to investors, funds that have collapsed, behind the scenes, fund manager Matthew Tannin called the subprime market "toast," and manager Ralph Cioffi moved $2 mn of his own money out of the funds without telling investors. Cioffi allegedly told a Bear economist in March: "Don't talk about [the February results] to anyone or I'll shoot you...I can't believe anything has been this bad," later noting "the worry for me is that subprime losses will be far worse than anything people have modeled." Both are under arrest.

    *In a rare bit of candid marksmanship, Arnold Kling, former economist at Freddie Mac, testified to Congress that a high-risk subprime loan could be "laundered" as a Wall Street triple-A-rated security, obscuring its true risks.

    *"Let's hope we are all wealthy and retired by the time this house of cards falters."--Email from an unidentified S&P employee who helped goldplate rubbish subprime securities with triple-A ratings.

    *"It could be structured by cows and we would rate it."--Email from an unidentified S&P employee about a structured finance deal.

    *After the auto execs flew to D.C. on private jets with tin cup in hand, they were shamed into driving fuel-efficient cars for the next Capitol Hill go around, to which Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH), said: "We didn't ask the CEOs of banks drive to town in a Wells Fargo armored truck."

    Congress Rushes to Defend Fannie and Freddie

    Prior to the bubble bursting, here is Congress defending Fannie and Freddie:

    "The more people, in my judgment, exaggerate a threat of safety and soundness, the more people conjure up the possibility of serious financial losses to the Treasury, which I do not see. I think we see entities [Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac] that are fundamentally sound financially and withstand some of the disaster scenarios."--Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.), who voted for the current bailout.

    "I do not think we are facing any kind of a crisis."--Rep. Barney Frank, (D-Mass.), on Fannie and Freddie.

    "I, just briefly will say, Mr. Chairman, obviously, like most of us here, this is one of the great success stories of all time."--Sen. Christopher Dodd (D-Conn.), who voted for the current bailout.

    "And my worry is that we're using the recent safety and soundness concerns, particularly with Freddie, and with a poor regulator, as a straw man to curtail Fannie and Freddie's mission."--Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY), who voted for the current bailout.

    "Yet another case of habitual self deception: "These assets are so riskless that their capital for holding them should be under 2%."--Franklin Raines, former head of Fannie Mae. Raines was forced to resign amidst a massive accounting scandal, was later sued to give up his compensation, though Fannie's corporate directors' insurance largely covered his forfeiture.

    "If I had better foresight, maybe I could have improved things a little bit. But frankly, if I had perfect foresight, I would never have taken this job in the first place."--Richard Syron, former head of Freddie Mac.

    Again, Has Your Head Exploded Yet?  

    So again blame the bailout on how generations were raised, on an overweening sense of narcissistic entitlement.

    Yes, Mr. Rogers helped those of us, too many of us, who had to endure obnoxious abusive parents to get through the day. I get that.

    But again, I'm talking about the culture of entitlement that's behind bailout fever.

    Miss Louise of Romper Room never encouraged this behavior--remember the Bumble Bee telling children to behave: "Do Bee a Don't Bee Doer"?

Kal Albert

As a Detroit conservative it's pretty simple to explain. Since the government is on a handout spree Detroit has suffered so bad for so long (doesn't matter who's fault anymore...who's fault was Katrina?) it should have been "bailed out" way before Wall Street. We always let others go first as we're polite...but before the typical Government response of "oh we can only rebuild the coast of Florida from the devastation caused by the known danger but built there anyway storms". It's long been Michigan's turn, since the Gov is handing out money, and we don't want to be last again. So stop handing out money....but do it after you save Michigan from ending up a Somalia like "Failed State".

December 12, 2008 at 2:41 pm

Lars

The UAW and their leadership did the same as the Unions did during the Eastern Airlines battle. BY simply refusing to take ANY cut in pay, the airlines went down the tubes. Well, lets see, other airlines picked up the slack and even though rocky, you can still fly anywhere you want. So, Big Three, suck it up and go bankrupt. You need NEW management anyway.

December 12, 2008 at 2:40 pm

jon

Well said and I agree, but it still doesn't address the true underlying problem. Even as Russia and China pursue capitalism, which has proven successful in the US, and THEY both depart from their communist ways, which have proven unworkable, the US is becoming more communist. All of our current problems can be attributed to socialist policies like the community renewal act passed by Carter and amended to its current poison pill status by Clinton. To make matters worse, now that the US has BO, it will accelerate. For America's best days, look behind you!

December 12, 2008 at 2:38 pm

1975 Tiger

Ms. MacDonald If only what you have written was encompassing all of the problems; actually might be as voluminous as the current ammended 1954 tax code. Lets look to the future, we still have to look forward to the current group of politicians continuing to grasp more power and further meddle in the markets. The same ones that lie to us daily will ultimately try to hand off the problems of $60 trillion of unfunded accrued debt for "Entitlements" to the next group of scoundrels. One wonders how many $100 bills will it take for our grandchildren to buy a loaf of bread?

December 12, 2008 at 2:36 pm

mediablamer

She makes a good point, but is it really fair to drag the good name of Mr. Rogers through the mud?

December 12, 2008 at 2:28 pm

lyn

Elizabeth, you couldn't be more right on.......one step further, the biggest bunch of me me mes, i'm entitled is the congress of the united states......they need to go....my question, is why do they keep getting elected, why don't the american people have the courage to vote them out........let's start over......they are supposed to represent US.......not themselves......

December 12, 2008 at 2:27 pm

Don Chance

Ms. McDonald, Your comments vindicate me. I am the professor who in July 2007 in the Wall Street Journal was quoted as saying that today's generation of young people were spoiled by Mr. Rogers. It got a lot of coverage, especially on Fox and Friends. It was of course just a metaphor for the entitlement generation but quite a few people took it literally and chastised me for several weeks for picking on him. I hope you will not suffer the same slings and arrows of abuse I did. But I am really glad to see that my comments had a lasting effect. Your analysis is very well stated and the reference to Rogers is clearly just a metaphor though some will not see it that way.

December 12, 2008 at 2:26 pm

eddie88

BEAUTIFUL! Our society today has this mind-set; Do What You Think Is Right or What You Think Is Wrong and Simply Allow Your Circumstances To Guide Your Choices. Thus; Abortion on demand, and Get what you want NOW....no one needs to wait! Take all you can get now, after all, you only go around once, and never forget, you're somebody too.... and when it's over here, it's over here!.... Thus; no thought of reaping what one sows! All I see today are young folks who are taught at an early age to stare into the pool of Narcissus.....and what really concerns me is what will they do when they realize it is only a reflection of themselves? Look out folks, cause the Inmates are in charge of the asylum!

December 12, 2008 at 2:26 pm

Sandy Berish

Romper, Bomper, Stomper, Do Tell me, tell me, tell me do... Have our annointed ones had fun today? I see Barney and Chris and Charlie and Franklin.....

December 12, 2008 at 2:24 pm

Dan Johnson

As a minor aside, I have a family member who works for a specialty transporter in Michigan. His company hauled the hybrid vehicles which Nardelli from Chrysler, and Waggoner from GM "arrived" in DC in, from Detroit to "just outside DC". Those two did NOT ride in a car from Detroit! They snuck into an airport outside DC, climbed out of their jets and met up with their cars to make a phony "grand entrance into DC". I wonder if the public is aware of this fact. Their arrogance is incredible.

December 12, 2008 at 2:18 pm

Tim Connor

Very well researched article, and well presented. As a country, we seem to have developed some wild hope that we can continue with these government-sponsored, taxpayer-funded "fixes" and - against any known business principles - everything will work out in the end. Since the 1930s, government has taken over retirement, then education, then retirement healthcare, so I suppose it looks logical to have it run conglomerate businesses. My main question is "When has government run any of these things well, and explain to me how this will be different?" If we go back to the Consitution, and what goverment SHOULD be running, we might start to get an inkling of what government's responsibilities should be. I think the founders had a better idea!

December 12, 2008 at 2:13 pm

Rick

Concur with your thoughts. UAW says this is all Republicans fault. NO problem with paying wages far above what work calls for to produce products vastly inferior to the competition. No problem with management incompetence. The problem is the Republicans in the Senate stand in the way of the Democrats paying back the unions for their support in winning the White House and a bunch of legislative seats. And I am fairly sure the Republicans are at fault for the Illinois Governor's problems, too. Just think what a spin they will put on it (Republican's fault, again) when they find more definitive evidence that Great Smiler-elect knew of the shenanigans - or criminal activity, as it would be called pre-Mr. Rogers. The Republicans TRUE fault is in not living up the ideology they espouse and saying one thing and then doing another. Yeah, we can all blame them for that.

December 12, 2008 at 2:10 pm

pat

Most days I make minimum wage or less at my retail business which I work at 7 days a week. I cannot afford employees! Is someone going to give me a bailout? I am forced to live within my means, meager as they are. I object to giving my taxes to those making millions off bonuses for failing businesses.

December 12, 2008 at 2:08 pm

Burnsie

Ms. MacDonald- I agree with you, I think this stems from a deep rooted psychosis of living in constant fear as the generation in power, the Boomers, have been. So the method is fear creates crisis creates overreaction and the cycle continues. They only know how to operate in crisis so that is the reality or environment they create and then try to "solve". Right now, I love my country but I really hate the people in goverenment power positions. Keep up the good works.

December 12, 2008 at 1:57 pm

Jerry

Most of our financial problems can be traced to a political culture rampant with corruption. Campaign Contributions larger then $10,000 are veiled bribes given to politicians for favors. Just look at who received large contributions from the companies who are getting bailouts! Someting stinks in Washington, and it is not the cheese!

December 12, 2008 at 1:57 pm

Weeping in Austin

EMAC, Well said! And about time. My grandparents are rolling in their grave at all this moronic selfishness. The only way I can calm their spirits is to make sure my grandchildren don't get corrupted or indebted by this silliness.

December 12, 2008 at 1:51 pm

borderplex

What she said! I agree with every word. I'm 68 years old and my parents were of the "Great Generation". I was raised with sayings like "A penny saved is a penny earned" and "Waste not, want not". My folks had a "Victory Garden" during World War II. My kids were raised on fresh vegetables from our family garden. Mr. Rogers and folks of his ilk came along and told my children not to pay attention to me or their mother because "they deserve" much better than what I offer. One of them, disappointed by life, is a drug addict. The other is earning six figures, wants more, and thinks Obama is the Messiah that is going to save us from ourselves. God help us all..!

December 12, 2008 at 1:50 pm

Paul Martin

Thank you so much for some words of sanity amidst the morass of convoluted double speak. Here's an idea, put the whole federal government, as well as any state or local goivernement that cannot pay its bills, into the bankruptcy courts for protection while they go through a restructuring of all programs, making them fiscally sound operations. The tough choices have to be made every day in America by all who live within their means. Let those who govern model it for the rest of us. PLEASE!!

December 12, 2008 at 1:43 pm

Gabriel

A BIG AMEN Sister!

December 12, 2008 at 1:37 pm

Tom

To: Elizabeth MacDonald From: Captain Kangaroo Subject: Blame Game If you plan on implicating any of our current circumstances on Mr. Moose, you will personally have to answer to Mr. Greenjeans. Regretfully, The Capt.

December 12, 2008 at 1:30 pm

Dennis

Absolutely the best analysis of what is going on. This sense of entitlement as well as our trusted government 'enabling the entitled' has led us to this point. My biggest concern is this, the overwhelming majority of the people were against the 700bn bailout and we got it anyway. OK, congress ruled against the people. Now, the senate has voted NO on the auto bailout, but, the Bush administation ( which I voted for twice ) is flipping off the Senate and saying we'll just use the TARP money. What is the sense of voting, our individual votes don't count and now it seems the Senate votes don't count. When did we turn into a dictatorship? Keep up the good work

December 12, 2008 at 1:14 pm

about this blog

  • Elizabeth MacDonald is the stocks editor for Fox Business Network. She is recognized as one of the top prize-winning business journalists in the country, and has received 14 awards, including the top prize in business journalism, the Gerald Loeb Award for Distinguished Business Journalism, and the Newswomen's Club of New York Front Page Award for Excellence in Investigative Journalism.