Emac's Stock Watch | Fox Business
  • October 3, 2008 03:54 PM EDT by Elizabeth MacDonald

    Ron Paul's Texas Straight Talk on the Bailout

    If there's anyone in Congress who should feel like he has been shouting into a field of cotton, it should be Congressman Ron Paul (R-Texas).

    And sometimes a journalist just needs to yield the platform for once, for God's sakes, to someone who is trying to bring some common sense to the debate.

    Because God knows we TV gasbags have done enough, doing our part to add to global warming, taking out Arctic glaciers on a daily basis.

    T. Boone Pickens, who now advocates a major wind energy plan, should realize that the Central Bank of Wind, the Saudi Arabia of Wind is not Tornado Alley--it stretches from right here in media land in New York City down to outside the halls of Congress.

    Yes, Dr. Paul has been criticized and ridiculed. By those who live in an echo chamber and don't give anyone except those who agree with themselves a fair hearing. It's time to listen to all points of view, because we are living through one of the rare times when the landscape of this economy is being permanently changed.

    I am printing below Dr. Paul's thoughts on the historic bailout of the financial sector.

    Dr. Paul is the leading spokesman in Washington for limited constitutional government, low taxes, free markets, and a return to sound monetary policies based on a commodity-backed currency, his bio reads.

    He is a strong advocate for sound monetary policy and is an unrelenting critic of the Federal Reserve's inflationary measures.

    Dr. Paul is known among both his colleagues in Congress and his constituents for his consistent voting record in the House of Representatives. Dr. Paul never votes for legislation unless the proposed measure is expressly authorized by the US Constitution, his bio notes.

    Dr. Paul serves on the House Financial Services Committee, the International Relations committee, and the Joint Economic Committee.

    And he is the author of several books, including Challenge to Liberty; The Case for Gold; and A Republic, If You Can Keep It. He has been a distinguished counselor to the Ludwig von Mises Institute, and is widely quoted by scholars and writers in the fields of monetary policy, banking, and political economy.

    Here now is Rep. Paul:

    Paul Fears Bailout Could Tank the Economy

    The following is taken from a news report quoting Dr. Paul:

    The so-called financial "bailout" package could end up tanking the economy, warns Paul. "We're trying to prop up bad debt," he warns.

    Congressman Paul argued that a bailout does not address the underlying problems that caused the current crisis.

    The bad debt should be "wiped off the books" rather than purchased by taxpayers, Paul argued. The Texas congressman said he would vote against the bill, citing a response of 9-1 against it by his constituents.

    On a more ominous note, Paul warned of lean economic times ahead. "We will have our recession," he said, warning that it could turn into a major "depression" if the bailout bill in its current form was signed into law. "We built this problem by...irresponsible spending," Paul said.

    Spending to Wipe Out Bad Debt Equals Inflation

    He said the bailout bill would make the economy worse. "It's propping up bad debt with more spending," he said. "As long as you can create new money, you create more inflation" he said, referring to the power of the Federal Reserve to introduce new money into the banking system.

    Before the late 1960s, the Fed had to keep a percentage of gold on hand for every Federal Reserve note it issued. These constraints were removed by Congress in the mid to late 1960s during the administration of President Lyndon Johnson, thus giving the Fed a blank check on how much currency it could put into circulation.

    It forced Johnson's successor, President Richard Nixon, to remove the final restraint, pegging the dollar to a fixed gold price. This created an inflationary spiral that was not quashed until the mid-1980s via the restrained monetary policy of then-Fed Chairman Paul Volcker.

    Paul's remarks indicated that he believes the economy could be headed for a similar inflationary spiral.

    But Paul had a few good things to say about the bailout bill. "I think there have been a few improvements," Paul said, citing tax breaks and cuts tacked on to the $700 bn in taxpayer-funded buyouts that could make the bill more appealing to legislators. "Maybe the markets will like that for a little while."

    Words of Warning

    Here is Rep. Paul on the biggest bailout in the government's history, words he wrote before the U.S. House of Representatives voted to approve the bill Friday:

    This time last week, the biggest bailout in the history of the world seemed to be a fait accompli. 

    Last weekend, the Fed Chairman and the Secretary of the Treasury had harsh words of doom and gloom for Congressional leaders, with the rest of the administration parroting along, and by last Monday it seemed both parties were about to fall in line and vote our Republic away by socializing the banking industry through this bailout. 

    Foolish business behavior was about to be rewarded, and propped up a little longer, the bubble blown a little bigger, and our coming Depression made that much greater, but then something happened on the way to the House floor.

    Citizens made their voices heard. 

    The real story behind the story in Congress this week was the thousands of calls and emails sent to Representatives, clogging up inboxes and even slowing down the House internet system. 

    Slowly, like the Titanic turning around, sentiments on the Hill shifted, and we heard Congressmen capitulating and changing their tune a little, desperately trying to find ways to salvage the bailout without completely enraging their constituencies.

    Now we hear about taxpayer protections, about golden parachutes, and about other nuances that hardly cover up the fact that we would be creating more money out of thin air and further devaluing the dollar! 

    The problem is not HOW the government is spending this money; it's the fact that the government is spending this money. We don't have it. We are already nearly $10 tn in debt, not including unfunded liabilities. 

    We already spend about $1 tn a year we don't have on our overseas empire. Now nearly $1 tn more is somehow supposed to magically appear and solve all our problems!  No -- creating more money might delay the inevitable for some well-connected banks on Wall Street, but in a few weeks we will find ourselves right back in this same position, but much poorer.

    The unfortunate thing is that we've already spent at least $700 bn on other bailouts that did not solve the problem. And while all this negotiation was taking place, the auto industry was quietly bailed out, with no controversy, no discussion, to the tune of $25 bn.

    Inevitably, it appears Congress will call their constituents' bluff and the bailout will pass, because that is the habit Wall Street and Washington have fallen into. People are right to be concerned about our financial future. 

    I've been talking for 30-some years about reasons we need to be concerned and change our ways. We find ourselves now in a position of no good options, and no silver bullets. 

    But the worst thing we can do is to compound our problems by intensifying the mistakes of the past. 

    We do have tough economic times ahead, no doubt, no matter what we do, even if we do nothing. 

    The question is, will we have the courage to take our medicine now and get it over with, or will we prolong the misery for many years to come? I'm less and less optimistic about the answer to that question.

Matt

I wish Dr. Paul was my congressman. I'm no genius and I'm certainly not a seer, but I can see the dark times ahead. These men and women we elect into office are supposed to intelligent people. For the most part, this is not the case.

October 3, 2008 at 5:09 pm

neal

He is right. Again congress did not listen to the people. You don't spend money to get out of debt. And buying "toxic loans" is not an investment.

October 3, 2008 at 5:08 pm

James Mallery

Ron is most likely correct. It is my belief that unless we can strongly encourage the resource development and manufacturing side of the economy, we will have to "inflate" our way out of this problem. Inflation is the enemy of the poor, the retired individuals, and wage earners. We are simply trying to prop up an already inflated real estate market that was "social engineered" by our well meaning Democratic "friends" who refused to allow banks to use a "reasonable" person standard in loan underwriting. This "bail out" will not solve the problem, only make it worst a few months or years from now.

October 3, 2008 at 5:00 pm

Stephen

Dr. Paul is speaking sense. However, I do not think our elected officials will do anything but kick the problem down the road until it becomes impossible to do so any longer. The monetary system will collapse before Congress acts responsibly.

October 3, 2008 at 4:59 pm

Peter

Emac, I have always followed your articles, and you are quite the intelligent person. You work extremely hard to break down the details so we all can understand the micro to the macro and how to connect the dots. More importantly, you have what the other writer Cody has: A desire to be honest. Your intelligence and honesty is a wonderful contribution to our society. Thank You for allowing Ron Paul another bit of platform.

October 3, 2008 at 4:59 pm

John Van Allen

I hardly recognize what America has become. Socialist. What a better country we would live in if Ron Paul were President. Wake UP America!

October 3, 2008 at 4:56 pm

AlpineCapitalist

Sadly Ron Paul is telling the truth. How did Americans become so ignorant of basic economic principles? Our Reps in congress either are as clueless as they sound or purposely deceptive by not pinning the source of problems on Fed policy, market manipulation, gov't support for Freddy and Fanny leading to malinvestment. There is not now or never been a government which can protect people against the market. It can only smooth things for short term gain with very big blow back later.

October 3, 2008 at 4:56 pm

Tom

All too unfortunately Congressman Paul is correct. This bill laden with "pork" and putting our government in to business using tax payer dollars is the height of socialism. There are too many free market ideas floating around that should have been put into effect before spending $700B plus on bad paper and all the legislator's pork projects. Yes, some things in the bill have merit. Overall, however, it's awful and America is in for a tough time. I feel sorry for the winner of the Presidential race. What a mess to step in to.

October 3, 2008 at 4:54 pm

Joe USA

When Ron Paul was a candidate he couldn't buy attention, now that we are headed for disaster everyone wants his opinion. It's basic finance. As a country we don't have the money. So we will print it, borrow it from overseas or raise taxes to cover it. These representatives are either irresponsible, criminal or just plain stupid. Remember their names, and vote them out!

October 3, 2008 at 4:49 pm

andrew

Thank you MRS. MCDonald! Great article and Please spread the word. I have been a Ron Paul advocate ever since I hear of his name in the Presidential race last year. I too have been learning from the Ludwig Von Misses school of economics and I too believe every word Ron Paul has said. I have challenged the political arena to the fullest and am quit certain I am being taxed with out any representation from my country (or what is left of it). This was one of the main reasons why we split from England many decades ago. Will the same thing happen in America? I think America was set-up perfectly with the constitution and our current politicians have no understanding of the constitution. Keep up the articles, we need to let as many people know...and no i am not a chicken little. The current administration are the chicken littles running around saying the sky is falling and scaring the people who thrive off of this economy. shame on them! Bunch of pessemistic immoral alturistic parrasites

October 3, 2008 at 4:48 pm

mr green

I am afraid that Rep Ron Paul may be correct. We are just delaying the problem. Our whole system is based on short term fixes. If it is US congress the fix is about one year, because we have to run again next year. If it is US Senate we may look at a 2 year period, because some are elected every two years. The CEO of big business is looking at 3 months, because they need good numbers for the quarterly report. I do hope Rep Paul is wrong, but I doubt that he is. This bail out is wrong and we and our children will pay for it in the future.

October 3, 2008 at 4:47 pm

Dean

Why is no one listening to dr. paul?????????? This country is finished.....after this bailout.... I hope all you people at fox news that spread propaganda for a living feel good about yourselves when this thing comes crashing down...... the dollar is finished and we are in for some very hard times..................... good luck.....

October 3, 2008 at 4:45 pm

Joey

American's are so stupid we can't even get out of our own way. Want proof of this? The only man who consistently upholds his oath to the constitution is considered a kook by the masses. I liken it to all the inmates of a mental hospital believing their doctor is the one who's crazy. Americans are dumb, fat, and uninformed. We can pack out football stadiums and Nascar tracks but we don't know sqwat about the Constitution, Liberty, or the Founders. We can quote irrelevant sport stats all day long. We get what we deserve. Despite what fluff candidates like Obama and McCain say about "America's best days being ahead", that's a big fat lie. The reality is, we peaked along time ago. We're on our way out.

October 3, 2008 at 4:44 pm

Buzz Gee

I am not a Ron Paul fan, but he has this correctly pegged. As an economist I have to say the biggest culprit here is "Easy Al" Greenspan. He is supposed to have been the adult in a room full of children (congress) playing their "spend money and buy votes" games. Al Greenspan was supposed to have been the cop, but instead he became the pusher of the drug of easy money. He abandoned his role at the Federal Reserve because he did not want to rain on this parade. And then he left town when the problems created by his easy money policies caught up to our economy. History will not judge him kindly.

October 3, 2008 at 4:43 pm

BHoy

Thanks for the good fight & words of wisdom but it's not just our money lost today.

October 3, 2008 at 4:40 pm

Charlie Thomas

We have just seen the proverbial final straw that will break the camel's back. God help us all.

October 3, 2008 at 4:39 pm

sj

I'm a 61 yr old retired military officer. Today is the first time I've ever been ashamed of my country and our form of government. Common sense and dignity no longer apply, and for some reason life is always supposed to go well, with no downturns. The 2 things my parents generation bragged about were WWII and the Great Depression and how they survived and the world got better. Like Mr. Paul said, it's time to take our medicine and get it over with.

October 3, 2008 at 4:38 pm

Bill_in_NYC

Why can't this man be president! Why does the media always have to cheer on big gov't and try to sell propoganda to people. Paul couldn't get 1 minute of airtime until this crisis and people all of a sudden realize that he is the smartest man on capital hill. Thanks for finally letting him tell it how it is but I fear it is much to late. The media in this country has turned into nothing but a bunch of whining, ivy-league educated, ideological, socialist trust fund babies with no interest in actually reporting the news or telling the truth. Main stream media outlets are generally nothing but propaganda. Give Ron Paul some coverage! He can lead this nation back to prosperity!

October 3, 2008 at 4:36 pm

Patsy

Dr. Paul is saying, and has said, what more than 90% of Americans believe to be absolutely true. Those of us who fully expect to work for what we get and expect to suffer or enjoy the consequences of our choices/actions, have precious few advocates and those advocates are not being heard ... thank the media. 99.9% of government officials, elected or otherwise put in office, in Washington serve only themselves. They have absolutely no interest in the welfare of anyone who cannot line their pockets with power and/or money. This is not just unethical, it is criminal ... perhaps even treasonous. My anger at these idiots knows no bounds. I am ready and eager to be a part of a groundswell of effort to "throw the bums out" - regardless of party - and see them prosecuted if possible!

October 3, 2008 at 4:34 pm

SC

We will not give up and we will continue to fight this reckless spending. Congress is probably scared now because we are watching every vote they make. I don't know if Obama or McCain would be worse, but what I'm hoping for is that all of Congress (except for Ron Paul) that is up for re-election gets thrown out this November. My personal hope is that Obama wins, but the Democrats lose Congress. That way we hopefully won't be going to any wars, at the same time we will be able to put a check on the crazy spending Obama planned. Obviously we don't have enough money, we didn't before, and we definitely don't now. If they really needed this bailout the only way they could've justified it is if they cut 700 billion in spending somewhere else. As it is, they put us in a deeper hole.

October 3, 2008 at 4:33 pm

R Coleman

I couldn't agree more!

October 3, 2008 at 4:29 pm

jeff

There is no shame and we are doomed.

October 3, 2008 at 4:28 pm

Big Yahoo Mike

1) Every incumbent running for office who voted yes on the bail out needs to be named by the media in the form of a list.... discussions about why they should be voted out of office... or why we thank them can begin now. 2) Same thing with our candidates.... Are they political party puppets or do they have American best interest guiding them? If they are puppets of their party - we should rebel by writting in Ron Paul as our next president. SY Mike

October 3, 2008 at 4:22 pm

Hannon

Ron Paul Revolution FOREVER!

October 3, 2008 at 4:21 pm

greg

Finally, someone giving the voice of reason its due. Ron Paul explained what was going to happen a decade ago, it happened and now he forewarns us of what is to come. Maybe we should listen this time.

October 3, 2008 at 4:19 pm

about this blog

  • Elizabeth MacDonald is the stocks editor for Fox Business Network. She is recognized as one of the top prize-winning business journalists in the country, and has received 14 awards, including the top prize in business journalism, the Gerald Loeb Award for Distinguished Business Journalism, and the Newswomen's Club of New York Front Page Award for Excellence in Investigative Journalism.

most popular posts